Cookham Parish Council

 

COOKHAM PARISH COUNCIL

 

Minutes of a Meeting of the PLANNING COMMITTEE held at the

Community Room on Tuesday, 22nd July 2008 commencing at 7.30 pm

 

PRESENT:       Cllr H.J. Woodbridge (Chairman), Cllr M. Barnes (Vice Chairman)

Cllrs M. Brar, P. Brockwell, M. Coker, D. Fry, G. Harris, M. Innes,

M-L. Kellaway, R. Piercey, D. Ricardo, Jean Stretton, John Stretton and

M. Wellman.

 

Also present:    Sonia Kapur (Maidenhead Advertiser), James Nadal (Marlow Free Press) and one member of public.

_________________________________________________________________________

OPEN FORUM Mr P. Ovstedal of Lightlands Cottage spoke about his concerns regarding Pln Appn 08/01608. He said the proposals were bulky, overly large and un-neighbourly. His garden would now be overlooked and he was also concerned that the extension would go so close to his boundary to threaten the viability of the mature golden hedge. He said these proposals would create a three storey home whereas the building style in this area was predominantly chalet-style homes.

It was AGREED to bring Pln Appn 08/01608 to the front of the agenda.

 

1.                  APOLOGIES AND DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST: Apologies were received from Cllr Hewer. Cllr Ricardo declared a personal interest in item 3 on the agenda. Cllr Fry and Harris declared a personal interest in item 5 on the agenda. Cllr John Stretton declared an interest as a member of the Borough Planning Panel and reserved the right to change his mind at a later stage. Cllr Piercey declared a personal interest in Pln Appn: 08/01673. Cllr Barnes declared a personal interest in Pln Appn: 08/01551.

 

2.                  PLANS CONSIDERED & DISCUSSED:

Planning

Ref:

Current Planning Applications

Decision

08/01608

 

(27/06/08)

Two storey side extension and loft conversion with front and rear dormers.

1 BARNFIELD CLOSE, Cookham.

Mr G Cooper

Cookham Parish Council refer this application to the Borough Planning Panel unless the Case Officer agrees with our objections.

OBJECTION: Contrary to Policies DG1, H10 and H11 – over-development and un-neighbourly. Unacceptable light pollution.

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = UNANIMOUS

08/01508

 

(17/06/08)

Construction of a carport and raising existing boundary wall to 2m high.

THE OLD SHIP, Sutton Road, Cookham.

Cookham Parish Council request that this application is referred to the Borough Planning Panel unless the Case Officer agrees with this objection.

OBJECTION to the raising of the wall as it changes the appearance of a building in the Conservation Area. No objection to the carport.

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = UNANIMOUS

08/01541

 

(19/06/08)

Single storey extension between house and outbuildings (annex).

TUGWOOD, Kings Lane, Cookham Dean.

Mr I Johnson

NO OBJECTION

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = 11

ABSTENTION = 3

08/01550

 

(20/06/08)

Replacement garage and new front boundary wall.

OLD WELL COTTAGE, School Lane, Cookham Dean.

Mr Michael Slater

OBJECTION to the wall as it will adversely impact on the Conservation Area. No objection to the garage.

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = 12 ABSTENTION = 2

08/01551

 

(23/06/08)

Two storey side extension and new front entrance porch.

2 WESTWOOD GREEN, Cookham Rise.

Mr Duncan Sturdy

NO OBJECTION: Cookham Parish Council comment that this application is yet another loss of a garage.

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = 13 ABSTENTION = 1

08/01562

 

(23/06/08)

Detached double garage.

WINTERDOWN, Stone House Lane, Cookham Dean.

Hencan South Limited

OBJECTION – Contrary to Policy GB4 – inappropriate development in the Green Belt. CPC noted concerns over the conversion of the garage in 08/01048. This new garage in unacceptable.

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = 10 ABSTENTION = 4

08/01566

 

(24/06/08)

Replacement rear balcony.

SHY HAMLET, Dean Lane, Cookham Dean.

Mr B Haynes

NO OBJECTION

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = 13 AGAINST = 1

 

08/01673

 

(07/07/08)

Replacement garage with games room over and single storey front extension.

WILDWOOD, Alleyns Lane, Cookham Dean.

Mr and Mrs D Collins

NO OBJECTION – on the condition that the games room is not used to run a business or for living accommodation.

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = 13

ABSTENTION = 1

 

Planning

Ref:

Amended Planning Applications

Decision

08/00207

 

(25/01/08)

Flood remediation scheme at Marsh Meadow and The Pound.

Marsh Meadow and The Pound.

NO OBJECTION

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = UNANIMOUS

Cookham Parish Council note that the EA are simply re-instating the flood risk before the bund was built. This scheme must be allowed to go ahead in order the protect Cookham residents.

Planning

Ref:

Works to Trees in Conservation Area

Decision

08/01661

 

(08/07/08)

Notification to fell one Cherry tree, reduce one Leyland hedge by 40%, crown reduce one Cherry by 10-15%, reduce a Beech hedge to 1.83m, remove one Leyland hedge and replace with a Beech hedge, and prune two Hollies.

WESTWARD HOUSE, Berries Road, Cookham.

Mrs Lucy Woodall

NO OBJECTION

VOTE: IN FAVOUR = UNANIMOUS

Planning

Ref:

Works to Trees Covered by TPO

Decision

08/01595

 

(30/06/08)

Consent to reduce main bough and crown and reduce decayed wood on one Ash tree.

WIND WHISTLE, Cockmarsh, Riverside, Bourne End.

T J B Moulsdale

REFER TO TREE OFFICER

Planning Ref:

Current Appeals

Planning Policies

08/00511

The erection of a timber wall on a barn on land at Hardings Farm.

HARDINGS FARM, Hardings Green, Cookham Dean.

Mr P D Richards and Mrs Richards

To be decided on the basis of Written Representations and a Site Inspection.  All comments must be received by 30th July 2008.  Address and DOE ref available in Parish Office

Planning Ref:

Appeal Decisions

Decision

07/02021

 

(23/07/07)

Retrospective application for office and entrance portico.

HARWOOD HOUSE NURSING HOME, Spring Lane, Cookham Dean.

Harwood House Nursing Home

APPEAL DISMISSED – Inappropriate development in the Green Belt. Contrary to structure plan policy DP3, local plan policy GB1 and advice PPG2,

Planning Ref:

Planning Decisions

Decision

08/01230

Two storey side extension.

SUNNYCOTE, The Pound, Cookham.

Bowen Evans Consultancy

PERMITTED

08/01060

Two storey side extension.  Single storey front and rear extensions.

57 WESTWOOD GREEN, Cookham.

Mr S Challis

PERMITTED

08/00746

Construction of 8 x 4 bedroom town houses and 1 x 4 bedroom, plus two bonus rooms detached house with garages, carport and modification to access.

LAND ADJACENT HEDSORDENE, Lower Road, Cookham.

The Edwards Irish Partnership

REFUSED – Due to proximity of access road to level crossing and contrary to Planning Policy Statement 1 and Policies R3 and IMP1 RBWM Local Plan.

08/01365

Listed Building Consent to construct a first floor side extension and undertake alterations.

RIVERBANK COTTAGE, Spade Oak Reach, Cookham.

Compton Lacey

GRANTED

08/01089

Two storey side/rear extension.

GARLAND COTTAGE, New Road, Cookham.

APPLICATION WITHDRAWN ON 23RD JUNE 2008

08/01107

Notification to fell one Beech tree.

GIBRALTAR HOUSE, Gibraltar Lane, Cookham Dean.

R Watts & Sons

APPLICATION WITHDRAWN ON 23RD JUNE 2008

08/01199

Open entrance porch.

SELBOURNE, Church Road, Cookham Dean.

JSA Architects

APPLICATION WITHDRAWN ON 25th JUNE 2008

08/01051

Construction of 2 no. detached four-bedroom houses with alterations to access following demolition of existing (Amendments to permission 03/40086).

FORMER APPLE ORCHARD, School Lane, Cookham.

Robert Rigby Architects Limited

PERMITTED

08/01134

Change of use of building from commercial to form a single residential dwelling.

OAKHOUSE, Lower Road, Cookham Rise.

Mr Thomas Neal

PERMITTED

08/01162

Change of use of shop from A1 (retail) to A3 (restaurants and cafes) with retail area.

8-12 THE ARCADE, High Street, Cookham.

Mr Christian Haw

PERMITTED

 

3.         TO RESPOND TO A REPORT FROM ENTEC UK RE: THE EA APPLICATION TO DELETE MAIDENHEAD DITCH WIDENING WORKS: Cllr Ricardo said that the North Maidenhead Bund would protect Cookham for a 1:60 year flood but not for any more severe flooding. The extra development in Cookham Rise will also

                                                                                                                                    671

add to the flow in the Fleet ditch – placing even more low-lying parts of Cookham Rise at risk. Cllr Wellman said that once construction is complete, the area would be enhanced. Concerns were also raised on the maintenance aspect. Attention was drawn to the Water Course Maintenance scheme mentioned in the Entec report. The view of the Parish Council was that planning permission should be granted and that cost should not compromise the safety of Cookham properties.

 

4.         TO APPROVE THE ANNUAL ACCOUNTS FOR 2007-2008 FINANCIAL YEAR – Cllr Fry attended the last meeting of the Finance and General Purposes Committee and wanted to encourage other Councillors to show more interest. On the proposition of Cllr P. Brockwell, seconded by Cllr John Stretton, it was AGREED unanimously to approve the accounts for the 2007-2008 Financial Year.

 

5.         TO CLARIFY THE RENT INCREASE IN THE 280 POLES OF GRAZING LAND AT ALLEYNS LANE ALLOTMENTS: Due to confusion on the actual figures agreed, it was necessary to reappraise this item to clarify the increase. The recommended increases were based on the sums paid by current allotment tenants who pay £10 for ten poles. On the proposition of Cllr John Stretton, seconded by Cllr M. Innes, it was AGREED to charge the following increases: Year 1 - July 2008 – 2009 an increase of £75 (on the £25 currently being paid). Year 2 - July 2009-2010 – an increase of a further £100 and in Year 3 - July 2010-2011 an increase of £80 to bring the total to £280 for the 280 poles. This was AGREED unanimously.

 

6.         TO CONSIDER THE NEXT ACTION FOR THE SURVEY ON ROAD SAFETY FOR WHYTELADYES LANE FROM CLLR HEWER: Although Fiona Hewer had presented the survey prior to becoming a parish councillor – and was currently away on holiday – the Clerk had promised to put the item on the agenda of the next available meeting. Cllr John Stretton spoke of his dismay that the survey results should include an attack on the Conservative-run administration at the Town Hall. He disputed the view that the Conservatives did not care about road safety. Cllr Stretton also referred to the accident statistics that claimed a total of three accidents over the past five years. Cllr Brar then challenged Cllr Stretton and said that he was now being political. She called to defer the item until Cllr Hewer was present. Cllr Fry queried whether the survey was the initiative of Cllr Hewer. Cllr Coker said that the statistics did not include the number of near misses in Whyteladyes Lane.

            After much confusion the following proposal was agreed. Cllr Fry proposed to keep the survey results on file and to address the issues at the same time as the Parish Council reviewed the forthcoming proposals from the new Traffic and Transport Working Group. This was seconded by Cllr Kellaway. VOTE: IN FAVOUR = 11, ABSTENTION = 3.

 

7.            CHAIRMAN’S SUBMISSIONS: The Chairman agreed to allow Cllr Brar to raise a second proposal that was not on the agenda. Cllr Brar proposed to present the petition to the Town Hall with no comments from Cookham Parish Council either in support or against the survey. It was AGREED to present the petition part of the survey to RBWM. VOTE: IN FAVOUR = 8, ABSTENTION = 6.

 

The meeting closed at 9.10pm 

home    top of page You may need to click more than onceback    any suggestions